Global Health Governance and the Challenge of Holding Power to Account
David McCoy, Anuradha Joshi, Rajat Khosla, Marta Schaaf and Alicia Ely Yamin (2024). Global Health Governance and the Challenge of Holding Power to Account. UNU International Institute for Global Health.
Document type:
Report
Collection:
-
Attached Files (Some files may be inaccessible until you login with your UNU Collections credentials) Name Description MIMEType Size Downloads Power___Accountability_Working_Paper__June_24.pdf Power & Accountability Working Paper, June 24.pdf 
application/pdf; 3.53MB -
Related Links Link Description 
http://dx.doi.org/10.37941/RR/2024/2 Full text from publisher -
Author David McCoy
Anuradha Joshi
Rajat Khosla
Marta Schaaf
Alicia Ely YaminTitle Global Health Governance and the Challenge of Holding Power to Account Publication Date 2024 Place of Publication Kuala Lumpur Publisher UNU International Institute for Global Health Pages 16 Language eng Abstract While there is much to celebrate about the many institutions, actors, and initiatives that form the global health system, there are also problems with how the system is governed. Some of these relate to inequities and unmanaged conflicts of interest that are rooted in power imbalances and which leave certain actors with excessive and undue influence. By contrast, poorer countries and communities with the biggest stake in the global health system working equitably, effectively, and efficiently have little power by which to hold the system accountable. This intersecting issue of power, accountability, and global health governance is the focus of this Working Paper. The paper is broken into three sections. The first section discusses the meaning of global health governance and the role of accountability within governance structures and systems in general. It describes the current system of global health governance as being nested within a wider system of global political and economic governance, shaped by international relations, globalisation, and the dominance of neoliberal ideas and policies in recent decades. This has seen, among other things, shifts of power from state-based actors and institutions to more distant and less accountable global actors, as well as from democratic and public institutions to private actors and market forces. In doing so, the Working Paper draws particular attention to the power and accountability of powerful private actors and whether they are sufficiently held accountable. The second section unpacks the concept of accountability and describes five elements that are required for accountability to function (standards; data and information; answerability; sanctions; and remedy). It highlights the importance of independence in accountability and the challenges of holding powerful actors accountable. It then presents a three-layered framework to map accountability as a component of good global health governance. The final section concludes by calling for more discussion about power and accountability in global health, while also emphasising the need for rigorous research in identifying and helping correct harmful and unhealthy accountability deficits. Keyword Global Health
Governance
Power
AccountabilityCopyright Holder UNU International Institute for Global Health Copyright Year 2024 Copyright type Creative commons DOI 10.37941/RR/2024/2 -
Citation counts 
Search Google Scholar
Access Statistics: 220 Abstract Views, 368 File Downloads - Detailed Statistics Created: Mon, 03 Jun 2024, 17:39:09 JST by Silvia Fancello on behalf of UNU IIGH