Independent Review and Investigation Mechanisms to Prevent Future Pandemics: A Proposed Way Forward

Lehtimaki, Susanna, Nishtar, Kassim, Reidy, Aisling, Darehshori, Sara, Painter, Andrew and Schwalbe, Nina (2021). Independent Review and Investigation Mechanisms to Prevent Future Pandemics: A Proposed Way Forward. United Nations University International Institute for Global Health.

Document type:

  • Attached Files (Some files may be inaccessible until you login with your UNU Collections credentials)
    Name Description MIMEType Size Downloads
    n2021-05-12_PB_Future_Pandemic_Response.pdf n2021-05-12_PB_Future_Pandemic_Response.pdf application/pdf 127.51KB
    nIndependent_Review_Final.pdf nIndependent Review_Final.pdf application/pdf 754.42KB
  • Sub-type Research report
    Author Lehtimaki, Susanna
    Nishtar, Kassim
    Reidy, Aisling
    Darehshori, Sara
    Painter, Andrew
    Schwalbe, Nina
    Title Independent Review and Investigation Mechanisms to Prevent Future Pandemics: A Proposed Way Forward
    Publication Date 2021-03
    Place of Publication Kuala Lumpur
    Publisher United Nations University International Institute for Global Health
    Pages 32
    Language eng
    Abstract The COVID-19 pandemic has created enormous challenges for national economies, livelihoods, and public services, including health systems. In January 2021, the World Health Organization proposed an international treaty on pandemics to strengthen the political commitment towards global pandemic preparedness, control, and response. The plan is to present a draft treaty to the World Health Assembly in May 2021. To inform the design of a support system for this treaty, we explored existing mechanisms for periodic reviews conducted either by peers or an external group as well as mechanisms for in-country investigations, conducted with or without country consent. Based on our review, we summarized key design principles requisite for review and investigation mechanisms and explain how these could be applied to pandemics preparedness, control, and response in global health. While there is no single global mechanism that could serve as a model in its own right, there is potential to combine aspects of existing mechanisms. A Universal Periodic Review design based on the model of human rights treaties with independent experts as the authorized monitoring body, if made obligatory, could support compliance with a new pandemic treaty. In terms of on-site investigations, the model by the Committee on Prevention of Torture could lend itself to treaty monitoring and outbreak investigations on short notice or unannounced. These mechanisms need to be put in place in accordance with several core interlinked design principles: compliance; accountability; independence; transparency and data sharing; speed; emphasis on capabilities; and incentives. The World Health Organization can incentivize and complement these efforts. It has an essential role in providing countries with technical support and tools to strengthen emergency preparedness and response capacities, including technical support for creating surveillance structures, integrating non-traditional data sources, creating data governance and data sharing standards, and conducting regular monitoring and assessment of preparedness and response capacities.
    Keyword Pandemic
    Copyright Holder The Authors
    Copyright Year 2021
    Copyright type All rights reserved
  • Versions
    Version Filter Type
  • Citation counts
    Google Scholar Search Google Scholar
    Access Statistics: 2057 Abstract Views, 2334 File Downloads  -  Detailed Statistics
    Created: Thu, 01 Apr 2021, 10:38:17 JST by Basilio Valdehuesa on behalf of UNU IIGH