Exploring human autonomy effectiveness: Project logic and its effects on individual autonomy
Muñiz Castillo, Mirtha R. and Gasper, Des (2009). Exploring human autonomy effectiveness: Project logic and its effects on individual autonomy. Maastricht University.
Document type:
Report
Collection:
-
Attached Files (Some files may be inaccessible until you login with your UNU Collections credentials) Name Description MIMEType Size Downloads wp2009-006.pdf PDF 
application/pdf 303.97KB -
Sub-type Working paper Author Muñiz Castillo, Mirtha R.
Gasper, DesTitle Exploring human autonomy effectiveness: Project logic and its effects on individual autonomy Publication Date 2009 Place of Publication Maastricht, NL Publisher Maastricht University Pages 29 Abstract We have proposed elsewhere an alternative analytical framework for project evaluation and a criterion of ���human autonomy effectiveness�۪ to examine the effects of aid projects on the lives, opportunities and capacities of participants (Mu̱iz Castillo & Gasper, 2009). A project is human-autonomy effective when it promotes an expansion of individual autonomy that allows people to support and sustain their own development, in a way that does not constrain other priority capabilities. In this paper, we explore how four aid projects influenced the autonomy of local participants, by examining their project logic. We elicit key assumptions behind the projects�۪ design and implementation; identify significant project practices (forms of interaction and practical strategies); and analyse the practices�۪ possible influence on the participants�۪ autonomy. The paper shows that we need to understand the project logic in a deeper way than through the conventional ���logical framework�۪ approach. Power relations between project stakeholders are crucial elements of the actual practices that influence the access to resources as result of the projects. Moreover, practices such as top-down design or excessive conditionality could harm participants�۪ autonomy despite being supportive to other goals, and thus have negative longer-run significance. When project practices constrain the opportunities and perceived competence of individuals to help themselves, the ���development�۪ or change promoted by those projects is not sustainable (Ellerman, 2006). Keywords: Autonomy, effectiveness, project logic, management practices, human development Copyright Holder n/a Copyright Year 2009 Copyright type All rights reserved -
Citation counts 
Search Google Scholar
Access Statistics: 576 Abstract Views, 300 File Downloads - Detailed Statistics Created: Fri, 13 Dec 2013, 12:13:29 JST